Sustainable Diets in Collective Catering: Developing a Menu Scoring System to Evaluate Environmental Performance

Food systems are major drivers of global environmental change, accounting for about one-third of global greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and contributing to land degradation, freshwater depletion, and biodiversity loss. Within this system, post-retail activities generate an estimated 18–20% of total food-related GHG emissions. In Europe, food service is responsible for roughly 12% of total food waste, making collective catering a strategic sector for sustainability interventions. Objective: Through menu design and composition, collective catering services can influence the environmental performance of thousands of meals served daily. This study introduces a novel meal-level scoring system—the App for the Environmental Impact Assessment of Dishes in Collective Catering (EcoRistApp, ERA)—designed to assess and communicate the environmental performance of institutional canteen dishes. Methods: EcoRistApp was developed and applied to a representative selection of first courses, second courses, and side dishes. Environmental impacts were quantified using Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) with SimaPro 9.5.5 software and the ReCiPe Midpoint (H) method. Normalized and weighted impact results were aggregated into a composite Environmental Impact Index (EII), which was then translated into a five-color interpretative scale to enhance usability and comprehension. Results: The analysis highlighted marked differences in environmental performance among dishes, largely driven by ingredient type and origin. Plant-based meals, such as lentil soup, consistently achieved lower impact scores, while dishes containing animal-derived ingredients, particularly beef and fish, showed higher impacts across multiple categories. Recipes combining high- and low-impact ingredients demonstrated potential for reducing overall environmental burdens. Conclusions: By converting complex LCA outcomes into an intuitive scoring system, EcoRistApp supports informed decision-making by catering operators and consumers, encourages plant-forward menu strategies, and contributes to the environmental transition of food service systems.