How far from identifiability? A systematic overview of the statistical matching problem in a nonparametric framework

Statistical matching consists in estimating the joint characteristics of two variables observed in two distinct and independent sample surveys, respectively. In a parametric set up, ranges of estimates for non identifiable parameters are the only estimable items, unless restrictive assumptions on the probabilistic relationship between the non jointly observed variables are imposed. These ranges correspond to the uncertainty due to the absence of joint observations on the pair of variables of interest. The aim of this paper is to analyze the uncertainty in statistical matching in a nonparametric setting. A measure of uncertainty is introduced, and its properties studied: this measure studies the “intrinsic” association between the pair of variables, which is constant and equal to 1/6 whatever the form of the marginal distribution functions of the two variables when knowledge on the pair of variables is only the one available in the two samples. This measure becomes useful in the context of the reduction of uncertainty due to further knowledge than data themselves, as in the case of structural zeros. In this case the proposed measure detects how the introduction of further knowledge shrinks the intrinsic uncertainty from 1/6 to smaller values, zero being the case of no uncertainty. Sampling properties of the uncertainty measure and of the bounds of the uncertainty intervals are also proved.