Radiotherapy for T1 carcinoma of the glottis

AIMS AND BACKGROUND: The management of patients with T1 carcinoma of the glottic larynx is controversial, because surgery and radiation therapy are reported to be effective treatments. Several studies have shown radiotherapy to be safe and effective, with a high percentage of voice preservation and minimal complications, but most Italian physicians prefer to surgically treat such patients. METHODS: From 1980 to 1990, 36 patients with stage I squamous cell glottic carcinoma were treated with radiotherapy alone at the institute of Radiology of University of Rome "La Sapienza". In all patients the irradiation fields were limited to the larynx, with field size ranging from 4 x 4 cm to 7 x 7 cm. Total tumor doses ranged between 51 and 70 Gy (median 60 Gy) with a mean number of 30 fractions of 2 to 3 Gy per fraction (3 or 5 fractions per week). RESULTS: After a median follow-up of 98 months, we observed an overall survival rate at 5 years of 91.4% and actuarial 10-year survival of 85.7%. Local control was achieved in 97.1% of cases, with an event-free survival of 94.2% at 5 and 10 years. No major complications like necrosis or persistent edema of the larynx were observed. Minor complications like dysphonia (8%) and dysphagia (5.5%) were temporary; laryngeal function was completely preserved at the end of therapy. Final voice quality ranged from good to excellent. CONCLUSIONS: Our series confirms that radiation therapy has a major role in the management of early glottic cancer, with results comparable to surgical approaches and with better voice preservation.