INTRODUCTION. The increase in autochthonous exotic arboviral cases in Europe, particularly in Italy, highlights the importance of monitoring the effectiveness of control measures against the major competent vector, Aedes albopictus. Pyrethroids are key tools for reducing mosquito abundance and disease transmission, but their effectiveness is challenged by the spread of resistance in mosquito populations, mainly due to their widespread use for nuisance reduction. This study aimed to assess the effectiveness of spraying Cypermethrin (+ Piperonyl-butoxide, PBO) through area-wide (non-targeted) versus targeted treatments in public schools on an Ae. albopictus population from a coastal town on the Adriatic Sea in the Abruzzo region (Francavilla a Mare, Italy), and to evaluate resistance to pyrethroids. Environmental persistence of pyrethroids inside and outside treated schools was also assessed. MATERIALS AND METHODS. Aedes albopictus females were collected before and after pyrethroid treatments using sticky traps and human landing catches in 10 schools subjected either to area-wide spraying or to targeted hotspot applications. Phenotypic resistance to permethrin (0.75%) and cypermethrin (0.05%) was assessed by WHO bioassays (WHO, 2022, pp. 21–43), either with or without pre-exposure to PBO. The mutation V1016G, strongly associated with target-site resistance, was PCR-genotyped in mosquito specimens collected before and after treatments, as well as in individuals surviving or dying after laboratory exposure (Pichler et al., 2021. Insects., 12:1). Environmental persistence of pyrethroids was quantified through chemical analysis of plates exposed during spraying in seven schools. RESULTS AND CONCLUSION. Modelling results showed that: i) only targeted treatments achieved statistically significant reductions in mosquito abundance (70% reduction, 5 days post-treatment) and biting rates (90% reduction); ii) no significant difference was observed in the frequency of the 1016G allele before and after treatments (22% and 21%, respectively); iii) mean mortality after exposure to cypermethrin (0.05%) was 89.4%, with full recovery of susceptibility after PBO pre-exposure, indicative of metabolic resistance; iv) mean mortality after exposure to permethrin (0.75%) was 92.7%, with no recovery after PBO pre-exposure, together with the presence of the 1016G allele in homozygosis in the five surviving specimens, indicative of target-site resistance. Chemical analysis confirmed outdoor persistence of cypermethrin (541 ng/cm²), PBO (136 ng/cm²), and tetramethrin (0.041 ng/cm²) five days post-treatment; minor residues were also detected indoors in schools. These results represent a first attempt to assess the effectiveness of different pyrethroid treatment schemes, demonstrating that area-wide spraying, widely implemented particularly in tourist coastal areas, fails to significantly reduce Ae. albopictus abundance and biting activity. Hotspot applications proved more effective, although residues were detected both outdoors and indoors. Limited but concerning evidence of both target-site and metabolic resistance mechanisms to pyrethroids was observed in the mosquito populations.

Pyrethroids effectiveness against Ae. Albopictus from field to laboratory in a touristic coastal area of Italy / Santarelli, G., Virgillito, C., Longo, E., Benco, E., Vitali, M., Castellani, F., De Marco, C.M., Pistilli, A., Pichler, V., Fusari, A., Massimiliano Bianco, P., Della Torre, A., Caputo, B.. - (2026). (XXXIV Congresso nazionale SOIPA Bologna ).

Pyrethroids effectiveness against Ae. Albopictus from field to laboratory in a touristic coastal area of Italy

Greta Santarelli;Chiara Virgillito;Eleonora Longo;Elisa Benco;Matteo Vitali;Carlo Maria De Marco;Verena Pichler;Alessandra Della Torre;Beniamino Caputo
2026

Abstract

INTRODUCTION. The increase in autochthonous exotic arboviral cases in Europe, particularly in Italy, highlights the importance of monitoring the effectiveness of control measures against the major competent vector, Aedes albopictus. Pyrethroids are key tools for reducing mosquito abundance and disease transmission, but their effectiveness is challenged by the spread of resistance in mosquito populations, mainly due to their widespread use for nuisance reduction. This study aimed to assess the effectiveness of spraying Cypermethrin (+ Piperonyl-butoxide, PBO) through area-wide (non-targeted) versus targeted treatments in public schools on an Ae. albopictus population from a coastal town on the Adriatic Sea in the Abruzzo region (Francavilla a Mare, Italy), and to evaluate resistance to pyrethroids. Environmental persistence of pyrethroids inside and outside treated schools was also assessed. MATERIALS AND METHODS. Aedes albopictus females were collected before and after pyrethroid treatments using sticky traps and human landing catches in 10 schools subjected either to area-wide spraying or to targeted hotspot applications. Phenotypic resistance to permethrin (0.75%) and cypermethrin (0.05%) was assessed by WHO bioassays (WHO, 2022, pp. 21–43), either with or without pre-exposure to PBO. The mutation V1016G, strongly associated with target-site resistance, was PCR-genotyped in mosquito specimens collected before and after treatments, as well as in individuals surviving or dying after laboratory exposure (Pichler et al., 2021. Insects., 12:1). Environmental persistence of pyrethroids was quantified through chemical analysis of plates exposed during spraying in seven schools. RESULTS AND CONCLUSION. Modelling results showed that: i) only targeted treatments achieved statistically significant reductions in mosquito abundance (70% reduction, 5 days post-treatment) and biting rates (90% reduction); ii) no significant difference was observed in the frequency of the 1016G allele before and after treatments (22% and 21%, respectively); iii) mean mortality after exposure to cypermethrin (0.05%) was 89.4%, with full recovery of susceptibility after PBO pre-exposure, indicative of metabolic resistance; iv) mean mortality after exposure to permethrin (0.75%) was 92.7%, with no recovery after PBO pre-exposure, together with the presence of the 1016G allele in homozygosis in the five surviving specimens, indicative of target-site resistance. Chemical analysis confirmed outdoor persistence of cypermethrin (541 ng/cm²), PBO (136 ng/cm²), and tetramethrin (0.041 ng/cm²) five days post-treatment; minor residues were also detected indoors in schools. These results represent a first attempt to assess the effectiveness of different pyrethroid treatment schemes, demonstrating that area-wide spraying, widely implemented particularly in tourist coastal areas, fails to significantly reduce Ae. albopictus abundance and biting activity. Hotspot applications proved more effective, although residues were detected both outdoors and indoors. Limited but concerning evidence of both target-site and metabolic resistance mechanisms to pyrethroids was observed in the mosquito populations.
2026
XXXIV Congresso nazionale SOIPA
04 Pubblicazione in atti di convegno::04d Abstract in atti di convegno
Pyrethroids effectiveness against Ae. Albopictus from field to laboratory in a touristic coastal area of Italy / Santarelli, G., Virgillito, C., Longo, E., Benco, E., Vitali, M., Castellani, F., De Marco, C.M., Pistilli, A., Pichler, V., Fusari, A., Massimiliano Bianco, P., Della Torre, A., Caputo, B.. - (2026). (XXXIV Congresso nazionale SOIPA Bologna ).
File allegati a questo prodotto
Non ci sono file associati a questo prodotto.

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/11573/1781982
 Attenzione

Attenzione! I dati visualizzati non sono stati sottoposti a validazione da parte dell'ateneo

Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? ND
  • Scopus ND
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? ND
social impact