Zero-leverage firms remain a puzzle in business studies. Traditional views focus on demand factors like financial flexibility or credit constraints, often conflating these elements (Strebulaev & Yang, 2013; Morais, Serrasqueiro & Ramalho, 2020). This research presents a supply-side mechanism linking environmental externalities to access to debt. Based on the 'brown premium' in equity markets (Bolton & Kacperczyk, 2021), creditors favor firms with high negative externalities because of strong cash flows, whereas they discount sustainable firms with high initial costs. This creates a supply constraint that precludes leverage for environmentally friendly firms. Using a bivariate probit model on 1,022 firms across 54 countries from 2011-2022, the results show that environmental impacts significantly reduce debt availability, especially for firms with low externalities. The study highlights the importance of joint demand-supply estimation to mitigate bias (Saona, San Martín & Vallelado, 2024), suggesting that capital markets may penalize green firms through debt rationing.
A demand and supply analysis of environmental externalities and firms’ zero debt policy / Renzi, A., Saona Hoffmann, P., Vagnani, G.. - (2026), pp. 1597-1602. (Sinergie-SIMA 2026 Management Conference Pavia ).
A demand and supply analysis of environmental externalities and firms’ zero debt policy
Antonio Renzi;Gianluca Vagnani
2026
Abstract
Zero-leverage firms remain a puzzle in business studies. Traditional views focus on demand factors like financial flexibility or credit constraints, often conflating these elements (Strebulaev & Yang, 2013; Morais, Serrasqueiro & Ramalho, 2020). This research presents a supply-side mechanism linking environmental externalities to access to debt. Based on the 'brown premium' in equity markets (Bolton & Kacperczyk, 2021), creditors favor firms with high negative externalities because of strong cash flows, whereas they discount sustainable firms with high initial costs. This creates a supply constraint that precludes leverage for environmentally friendly firms. Using a bivariate probit model on 1,022 firms across 54 countries from 2011-2022, the results show that environmental impacts significantly reduce debt availability, especially for firms with low externalities. The study highlights the importance of joint demand-supply estimation to mitigate bias (Saona, San Martín & Vallelado, 2024), suggesting that capital markets may penalize green firms through debt rationing.I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.


