The study, which builds on broader research into the transformation of the Theatre of Marcellus, examines two architectural details depicted on folios 536 Av and 571 Ar, preserved in the Gabinetto Nazionale dei Disegni e delle Stampe degli Uffizi. These architectural details, unanimously recognized as the work of Baldassarre Peruzzi, are indicated in current literature as elements of the entablature of the Theatre of Marcellus. The study, however, revealed that both refer to a different monument. The drawings, in fact, represent two mirror-image architectural elements of the same architectural detail: the entablature of the ‘peperino portico’ of the Forum Holitorium. In addition to this important development, direct analysis of the two folios, conducted at the Gabinetto degli Uffizi, also reconstructs the process of formation of the two drawings, which has allowed us to identify their similarities and differences. Comparison with the architectural text they represent has made it possible to identify the derivations of one from the other and of both from the monument. This allowed the reconstruction of the coat of stemma codicum through observation of errors and corrections. The measurement procedure was then identified, also taking into account the obstacles due to pre-existing medieval structures, no longer present after the interventions of the 1930s. Furthermore, the subdivision of the unit of measurement used was identified (through comparison with the corpus of Peruzzi's drawings): the division of the unit of measurement used: the ‘palmo’ divided into eight parts and each part into four; a division commonly used by Peruzzi for the rendering of non-detailed architectural elements. The study highlights the different focus on the monument in the two drawings: an overall analysis aimed at identifying the proportional relationships that could lead to an 'ideal' restitution, from which to draw for the creation of the new one (571 Ar); rigorous attention to the material composition of the structure with meticulous measurement taking, aimed more at the technological aspect than at the architectural forms full of indications for a precise graphic restitution (536 Av). The drawings, read in sequence (and compared with the architectural text), therefore represent two moments in the approach to the direct study of the monument, and offer a singular and unprecedented cultural cross-section of the early sixteenth century, capable of rethinking Peruzzi's own relationship with the Ancient, which is much more complex, sensitive and articulated.

Note a margine di due disegni cinquecenteschi. Contributo alla comprensione dell’architettura antica / Montanari, V.. - In: QUADERNI DELL’ISTITUTO DI STORIA DELL’ARCHITETTURA. - ISSN 0485-4152. - n.s., fascc. 44-50 (2004-2007) «Quaderni dell’Istituto di storia dell’architettura»(2007), pp. 167-178.

Note a margine di due disegni cinquecenteschi. Contributo alla comprensione dell’architettura antica

Valeria Montanari
2007

Abstract

The study, which builds on broader research into the transformation of the Theatre of Marcellus, examines two architectural details depicted on folios 536 Av and 571 Ar, preserved in the Gabinetto Nazionale dei Disegni e delle Stampe degli Uffizi. These architectural details, unanimously recognized as the work of Baldassarre Peruzzi, are indicated in current literature as elements of the entablature of the Theatre of Marcellus. The study, however, revealed that both refer to a different monument. The drawings, in fact, represent two mirror-image architectural elements of the same architectural detail: the entablature of the ‘peperino portico’ of the Forum Holitorium. In addition to this important development, direct analysis of the two folios, conducted at the Gabinetto degli Uffizi, also reconstructs the process of formation of the two drawings, which has allowed us to identify their similarities and differences. Comparison with the architectural text they represent has made it possible to identify the derivations of one from the other and of both from the monument. This allowed the reconstruction of the coat of stemma codicum through observation of errors and corrections. The measurement procedure was then identified, also taking into account the obstacles due to pre-existing medieval structures, no longer present after the interventions of the 1930s. Furthermore, the subdivision of the unit of measurement used was identified (through comparison with the corpus of Peruzzi's drawings): the division of the unit of measurement used: the ‘palmo’ divided into eight parts and each part into four; a division commonly used by Peruzzi for the rendering of non-detailed architectural elements. The study highlights the different focus on the monument in the two drawings: an overall analysis aimed at identifying the proportional relationships that could lead to an 'ideal' restitution, from which to draw for the creation of the new one (571 Ar); rigorous attention to the material composition of the structure with meticulous measurement taking, aimed more at the technological aspect than at the architectural forms full of indications for a precise graphic restitution (536 Av). The drawings, read in sequence (and compared with the architectural text), therefore represent two moments in the approach to the direct study of the monument, and offer a singular and unprecedented cultural cross-section of the early sixteenth century, capable of rethinking Peruzzi's own relationship with the Ancient, which is much more complex, sensitive and articulated.
2007
Baldassarre Peruzzi, Foro Olitorio, Teatro di Marcello, disegni
01 Pubblicazione su rivista::01a Articolo in rivista
Note a margine di due disegni cinquecenteschi. Contributo alla comprensione dell’architettura antica / Montanari, V.. - In: QUADERNI DELL’ISTITUTO DI STORIA DELL’ARCHITETTURA. - ISSN 0485-4152. - n.s., fascc. 44-50 (2004-2007) «Quaderni dell’Istituto di storia dell’architettura»(2007), pp. 167-178.
File allegati a questo prodotto
File Dimensione Formato  
Montanari_Note a margine di due disegni cinquecenteschi_2007.pdf

solo gestori archivio

Tipologia: Versione editoriale (versione pubblicata con il layout dell'editore)
Licenza: Tutti i diritti riservati (All rights reserved)
Dimensione 9.45 MB
Formato Adobe PDF
9.45 MB Adobe PDF   Contatta l'autore

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/11573/1775245
Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? ND
  • Scopus ND
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? ND
social impact