Fewstudies have considered if a posteriori dietary patterns (DPs) are generalizable across different centers or studies, or if they are consistently seen over time.Todate,nosystematicsearchoftheliteratureonthesetopicshasbeencarriedout.Ascopingreviewwasconductedthroughasystematic search on the PubMeddatabase.Inthecurrentreview,weincludedthe34articlesexaminingtheextenttowhichaposterioriDPswereconsistently seen: 1) across centers from the same study or across different studies potentially representing different populations or countries (here indicated as cross-study reproducibility) and 2) over longer time periods (i.e., ≥2 y) (here indicated as stability over time). Selected articles (published in 19812019, 32% from 2010 onwards) were based on observational studies, mostly from Europe and North America. Five articles were based on children and/or adolescents and 14 articles included adults (2 men; 12 women,ofwhom3werepregnantwomen).AposterioriDPsweremostlyderived(32 articles) with principal components or factor analyses. Among the 9 articles assessing DP reproducibility across studies (number of centers/studies: 2–27; median: 3), 5 provided a formal assessment using statistical methods (4 index-based approaches of different complexity, 1 statistical model). A median of 4 DPs was reproduced across centers/studies (range: 1–7). Among the 25 articles assessing DP stability over time (number of timeoccasions: 2–6; median: 3), 19 provided a formal assessment with statistical methods (17 index-based and/or test-based approaches, 1 statistical model, 1 with both strategies). The number and composition of DPs remained mostly stable over time. Based on the limited evidence collected, most identified DPsshowedgoodreproducibilityacrossstudies andstability over time.However,whenpresentwithinthesinglestudies,thecriteria for the formal assessment of cross-study reproducibility or stability over time were generally very basic
Reproducibility of A Posteriori Dietary Patterns across Time and Studies: A Scoping Review / Edefonti, V., De Vito, R., Salvatori, A., Bravi, F., Patel, L., Dalmartello, M., Ferraroni, M.. - In: ADVANCES IN NUTRITION. - ISSN 2161-8313. - (2020), pp. 1255-1281. [10.1093/advances/nmaa032]
Reproducibility of A Posteriori Dietary Patterns across Time and Studies: A Scoping Review
De Vito R;
2020
Abstract
Fewstudies have considered if a posteriori dietary patterns (DPs) are generalizable across different centers or studies, or if they are consistently seen over time.Todate,nosystematicsearchoftheliteratureonthesetopicshasbeencarriedout.Ascopingreviewwasconductedthroughasystematic search on the PubMeddatabase.Inthecurrentreview,weincludedthe34articlesexaminingtheextenttowhichaposterioriDPswereconsistently seen: 1) across centers from the same study or across different studies potentially representing different populations or countries (here indicated as cross-study reproducibility) and 2) over longer time periods (i.e., ≥2 y) (here indicated as stability over time). Selected articles (published in 19812019, 32% from 2010 onwards) were based on observational studies, mostly from Europe and North America. Five articles were based on children and/or adolescents and 14 articles included adults (2 men; 12 women,ofwhom3werepregnantwomen).AposterioriDPsweremostlyderived(32 articles) with principal components or factor analyses. Among the 9 articles assessing DP reproducibility across studies (number of centers/studies: 2–27; median: 3), 5 provided a formal assessment using statistical methods (4 index-based approaches of different complexity, 1 statistical model). A median of 4 DPs was reproduced across centers/studies (range: 1–7). Among the 25 articles assessing DP stability over time (number of timeoccasions: 2–6; median: 3), 19 provided a formal assessment with statistical methods (17 index-based and/or test-based approaches, 1 statistical model, 1 with both strategies). The number and composition of DPs remained mostly stable over time. Based on the limited evidence collected, most identified DPsshowedgoodreproducibilityacrossstudies andstability over time.However,whenpresentwithinthesinglestudies,thecriteria for the formal assessment of cross-study reproducibility or stability over time were generally very basic| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Edefonti_reproducibility_2020.pdf
accesso aperto
Tipologia:
Versione editoriale (versione pubblicata con il layout dell'editore)
Licenza:
Tutti i diritti riservati (All rights reserved)
Dimensione
499.05 kB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
499.05 kB | Adobe PDF |
I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.


