The effective use of dietary patterns (DPs) remains limited. There is a need to assess their consistency over multiple administrations of the same dietary source, different dietary sources, or across different studies. Similarly, their generalizability should be based on a previous assessment ofDP constructvalidity. However,todate,nosystematicreviewsofreproducibilityandvalidityofaposterioriDPshavebeencarriedout.Inaddition,several methodological questions related to their identification are still open and prevent a fair comparison of epidemiological results on DPs and disease. A systematic review of the literature on the PubMed database was conducted. We identified 218 articles, 64 of which met the inclusion criteria. Of these, the 38 articles dealing with reproducibility and relative and construct validity of DPs were included. These articles (published in 19992017, 53% from 2010 onwards) were based on observational studies conducted worldwide. The 14 articles that assessed DP reproducibility across different statistical solutions examined different research questions. Included were: the number of food groups or subjects; input variable format (as well as adjustment for energy intake); algorithms andthenumberofDPstoretaininclusteranalysis;rotationmethod;andscorecalculationinfactor analysis. However, we identified at most 3 articles per research question on DP reproducibility across statistical solutions. From another 15 articles, reproducibility of DPs over shorter (≤1 y) time periods was generally good and higher than DP relative validity (as measured across different dietary sources). Confirmatory factor analysis was used in 15 of the included articles. It provided reassuring results in identifying valid dietary constructs characterizing the populations under consideration.Basedontheavailableevidence,onlysuggestiveconclusionscanbederivedonreproducibility across different statistical solutions. Nevertheless, most identified DPs showed good reproducibility, fair relative validity, and good construct validity.

Reproducibility and Validity of A Posteriori Dietary Patterns: A Systematic Review / Edefonti, V., De Vito, R., Salvatori, A., Bravi, F., Patel, L., Dalmartello, M., Ferraroni, M.. - In: ADVANCES IN NUTRITION. - ISSN 2161-8313. - (2020), pp. 293-326.

Reproducibility and Validity of A Posteriori Dietary Patterns: A Systematic Review

De Vito R;
2020

Abstract

The effective use of dietary patterns (DPs) remains limited. There is a need to assess their consistency over multiple administrations of the same dietary source, different dietary sources, or across different studies. Similarly, their generalizability should be based on a previous assessment ofDP constructvalidity. However,todate,nosystematicreviewsofreproducibilityandvalidityofaposterioriDPshavebeencarriedout.Inaddition,several methodological questions related to their identification are still open and prevent a fair comparison of epidemiological results on DPs and disease. A systematic review of the literature on the PubMed database was conducted. We identified 218 articles, 64 of which met the inclusion criteria. Of these, the 38 articles dealing with reproducibility and relative and construct validity of DPs were included. These articles (published in 19992017, 53% from 2010 onwards) were based on observational studies conducted worldwide. The 14 articles that assessed DP reproducibility across different statistical solutions examined different research questions. Included were: the number of food groups or subjects; input variable format (as well as adjustment for energy intake); algorithms andthenumberofDPstoretaininclusteranalysis;rotationmethod;andscorecalculationinfactor analysis. However, we identified at most 3 articles per research question on DP reproducibility across statistical solutions. From another 15 articles, reproducibility of DPs over shorter (≤1 y) time periods was generally good and higher than DP relative validity (as measured across different dietary sources). Confirmatory factor analysis was used in 15 of the included articles. It provided reassuring results in identifying valid dietary constructs characterizing the populations under consideration.Basedontheavailableevidence,onlysuggestiveconclusionscanbederivedonreproducibility across different statistical solutions. Nevertheless, most identified DPs showed good reproducibility, fair relative validity, and good construct validity.
2020
a posteriori dietary patterns; cluster analysis; construct validity of dietary patterns; consistency of dietary patterns; factor analysis; generalizability of dietary patterns; reproducibility of dietary patterns; relative validity of dietary patterns; validity of dietary patterns
01 Pubblicazione su rivista::01a Articolo in rivista
Reproducibility and Validity of A Posteriori Dietary Patterns: A Systematic Review / Edefonti, V., De Vito, R., Salvatori, A., Bravi, F., Patel, L., Dalmartello, M., Ferraroni, M.. - In: ADVANCES IN NUTRITION. - ISSN 2161-8313. - (2020), pp. 293-326.
File allegati a questo prodotto
File Dimensione Formato  
Edefonti_reproducibility-and-validity_2020.pdf

accesso aperto

Tipologia: Versione editoriale (versione pubblicata con il layout dell'editore)
Licenza: Tutti i diritti riservati (All rights reserved)
Dimensione 1.28 MB
Formato Adobe PDF
1.28 MB Adobe PDF

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/11573/1741954
Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? 32
  • Scopus 36
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? 40
social impact