The article, after describing the main theses defended by the Spanish doctrine in relation to the legitimate share in the Civil Code, proposes a reconstruction of the protection of the legitimate shareholders. Starting from the idea that there is a difference between the legitimate share and the inheritance quota and from the consideration that, in the absence of injury, the legitimate share has no right of action, it is stated that the interest protectedby the Civil Code is the material legitimate share. In order for the legitimated beneficiaries to be able to obtain the material reserved share, the law attributes the action of supplementation and the action of reduction. This is a single action, the effect of which is to render ineffective the provisions detrimental to the legitimated party. This results in a redefinition of the parts of the inheritance that allows the legitimated person to obtain the reserved portion. In the absence of a redefinition of the inheritance shares, it is not rationally possible to explain the title of acquisition of the successor in title, nor the technical mechanism by virtue of which it is carried out.

La protección de los herederos forzosos. La acción de reducción / Barba, Vincenzo. - In: ANUARIO DE DERECHO CIVIL. - ISSN 0210-301X. - 77:4 (octubre-diciembre)(2024), pp. 1523-1568. [10.53054/adc.v77i4.10637]

La protección de los herederos forzosos. La acción de reducción

Vincenzo Barba
2024

Abstract

The article, after describing the main theses defended by the Spanish doctrine in relation to the legitimate share in the Civil Code, proposes a reconstruction of the protection of the legitimate shareholders. Starting from the idea that there is a difference between the legitimate share and the inheritance quota and from the consideration that, in the absence of injury, the legitimate share has no right of action, it is stated that the interest protectedby the Civil Code is the material legitimate share. In order for the legitimated beneficiaries to be able to obtain the material reserved share, the law attributes the action of supplementation and the action of reduction. This is a single action, the effect of which is to render ineffective the provisions detrimental to the legitimated party. This results in a redefinition of the parts of the inheritance that allows the legitimated person to obtain the reserved portion. In the absence of a redefinition of the inheritance shares, it is not rationally possible to explain the title of acquisition of the successor in title, nor the technical mechanism by virtue of which it is carried out.
2024
El artículo, tras describir las principales tesis defendidas por la doctrina española e italiana en relación con la legítima, propone una reconstrucción de la protección de los legitimarios en el Código civil español. Partiendo de la idea de que existe una diferencia entre la legítima y la cuota hereditaria y de la consideración de que, en ausencia de lesión, el legitimario carece de cualquier acción, se afirma que el interés protegido por el Código Civil es la legítima material. La ley concede a los legitimarios tanto la acción de complemento como la acción de reducción, permitiéndoles así asegurar su legítima material. Se trata de una única acción, cuya consecuencia es dejar sin efecto las disposiciones que perjudican al legitimario. Se produce así una redefinición de las cuotas hereditarias que permite al legitimario conseguir la legítima. En ausencia de una redefinición de las cuotas hereditarias, es difícil racional y dogmáticamente explicar el título de adquisición del legitimario, y el mecanismo técnico en virtud del cual se realiza.
Herederos forzosos; legitimarios; legítima; complemento de la legítima; suplemento de la legítima; reducción de disposiciones lesivas; reducción de instituciones de herederos; reducción de legados; reducción de donaciones; cuotas hereditarias; partición de la herencia; caudal hereditario.
01 Pubblicazione su rivista::01a Articolo in rivista
La protección de los herederos forzosos. La acción de reducción / Barba, Vincenzo. - In: ANUARIO DE DERECHO CIVIL. - ISSN 0210-301X. - 77:4 (octubre-diciembre)(2024), pp. 1523-1568. [10.53054/adc.v77i4.10637]
File allegati a questo prodotto
File Dimensione Formato  
Barba_Protección_2024.pdf

solo gestori archivio

Tipologia: Versione editoriale (versione pubblicata con il layout dell'editore)
Licenza: Tutti i diritti riservati (All rights reserved)
Dimensione 255.99 kB
Formato Adobe PDF
255.99 kB Adobe PDF   Contatta l'autore

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/11573/1734144
Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? ND
  • Scopus ND
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? ND
social impact