BACKGROUND: Enrichment strategies from clinical trials for progressive systemic sclerosis-associated interstitial lung disease (SSc-ILD) have not been tested in a real-life cohort.RESEARCH QUESTION: Do enrichment strategies for progressive ILD impact efficacy, repre-sentativeness, and feasibility in patients with SSc-ILD from the European Scleroderma Trials and Research (EUSTAR) database?STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS: We applied the inclusion criteria of major recent SSc-ILD trials (Study of the Efficacy and Safety of Tocilizumab in Participants With Systemic Sclerosis [focuSSced], Scleroderma Lung Study II [SLS II], and Safety and Efficacy of Nintedanib in Systemic Sclerosis [SENSCIS]) and assessed progressive ILD, which was defined as absolute change in FVC and as significant progression (FVC decline $10%). Data were compared with all patients and with patients who did not fulfill any inclusion criteria. RESULTS: In total, 2,258 patients with SSc-ILD were included: 31.2% of the patients met SENSCIS criteria; 5.8% of the patients met SLS II criteria; 1.6% of the patients met focuSSced criteria, and 67.7% (1,529) of the patients did not meet any criteria. In the first 12 + 3 months, the absolute FVC decline in all patients and in patients who fulfilled criteria from SENSCIS was -0.1%, in patients who fulfilled criteria from focuSSced was -3.7%, and in patients who fulfilled criteria from SLS II was 2.3%, with accompanying more progressors in focuSSced. The patient populations that fulfilled the different study inclusion criteria significantly differed in various clinical parameters. In the second 12-month period, SENSCIS-enriched patients had a further absolute FVC% decline as described for the total cohort. In contrast, patients who fulfilled the focuSSced and SLS II criteria showed numeric improvement of lung function. There were no significant associations of enrichment criteria and ILD progression.INTERPRETATION: The application of enrichment criteria from previous clinical trials showed enrichment for progression with variable success, which led to selected patient populations reducing feasibility of recruitment. These findings are important for future clinical trial design and interpretation of the results of published trials.CHEST 2023; 163(3):586-598
Cohort Enrichment Strategies for Progressive Interstitial Lung Disease in Systemic Sclerosis From European Scleroderma Trials and Research / Hoffmann-Vold, Anna-Maria; Brunborg, Cathrine; Airò, Paolo; Ananyeva, Lidia P.; Czirják, László; Guiducci, Serena; Hachulla, Eric; Li, Mengtao; Mihai, Carina; Riemekasten, Gabriela; Sfikakis, Petros P.; Valentini, Gabriele; Kowal-Bielecka, Otylia; Allanore, Yannick; Distler, Oliver; Vacca, Alessandra; Giollo, Alessandro; Balbir-Gurman, Alexandra; Gheorghiu, Ana Maria; Marcoccia, Antonella; Herrick, Ariane; Radic, Mislav; Stamenkovic, Bojana; Anic, Branimir; Granel, Brigitte; Ribi, Camillo; Selmi, Carlo Francesco; Carlos de la Puente, Milano; de Souza Müller, Carolina; Denton, Christopher; Kayser, Cristiane; Tanaseanu, Cristina-Mihaela; Majewski, Dominik; Rimar, Doron; Krasowska, Dorota; Veale, Douglas; Walker, Ulrich; Kerzberg, Eduardo; Rezus, Elena; Zanatta, Elisabetta; Siegert, Elise; De Langhe, Ellen; Oksel, Fahrettin; Ingegnoli, Francesca; Cantatore, Francesco Paolo; Szücs, Gabriela; Cuomo, Giovanna; Seskute, Goda; Litinsky, Vilniusira; Castellví, Ivan; Morovic-Vergles, Jadranka; Sibilia, Jean; Henes, Jörg; Solanki, Kamal; Perdan-Pirkmajer, Katja; Herrmann, Kristine; Saketkoo, Lesley Ann; Stamp, Lisa; Mouthon, Luc; Salvador, Maria João; Pozzi, Maria Rosa; Üprus, Maria; Vanthuyne, Marie; Engelhart, Merete; Köhm, Michaela; Iudici, Michele; Inanc, Murat; Fathi, Nihal; Pamuk, Nuri; García de la Peña Lefebv, Paloma; Carreira, Patricia E.; Bancel, Dominique Farge; Moroncini, Luca; Montecucco, C.; Ancuta, Codrina; Sunderkötter, Cord; Müller-Ladner, Ulf; Rosato, Edoardo; Kucharz, Eugene J.; Iannone, Florenzo; Del Galdo, Francesco; Poormoghim, Hadi; Kötter, Ina; Distler, Jörg; Cutolo, Maurizio; Tikly, Mohammed; Damjanov, Nemanja; Hunzelmann, Nicolas; Vlachoyiannopoulos, P.; Hasler, Paul; Sarzi Puttini, Piercarlo; Wiland, Piotr; Becvar, Radim; Yavuz, Sule; Zdrojewski, Zbigniew; Pellerito, Raffaele; Foti, Rosario; Ionescu, Ruxandra Maria; Adler, Sabine; Kahl, Sarah; Moiseev, Sergey; Stebbings, Simon; Rednic, Simona; Negrini, Simone; Heitmann, Stefan; Ullman, Susanne; Agachi, Svetlana; Martin, Thierry; Schmeiser, Tim; Riccieri, Valeria; Smith, Vanessa; Bernardino, Vera; Ortiz-Santamaria, Vera; Hsu, Vivien M.; Abdel Atty Mohamed, Walid Ahmed. - In: CHEST. - ISSN 0012-3692. - 163:3(2023), pp. 586-598. [10.1016/j.chest.2022.09.044]
Cohort Enrichment Strategies for Progressive Interstitial Lung Disease in Systemic Sclerosis From European Scleroderma Trials and Research
Rosato, EdoardoMembro del Collaboration Group
;
2023
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Enrichment strategies from clinical trials for progressive systemic sclerosis-associated interstitial lung disease (SSc-ILD) have not been tested in a real-life cohort.RESEARCH QUESTION: Do enrichment strategies for progressive ILD impact efficacy, repre-sentativeness, and feasibility in patients with SSc-ILD from the European Scleroderma Trials and Research (EUSTAR) database?STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS: We applied the inclusion criteria of major recent SSc-ILD trials (Study of the Efficacy and Safety of Tocilizumab in Participants With Systemic Sclerosis [focuSSced], Scleroderma Lung Study II [SLS II], and Safety and Efficacy of Nintedanib in Systemic Sclerosis [SENSCIS]) and assessed progressive ILD, which was defined as absolute change in FVC and as significant progression (FVC decline $10%). Data were compared with all patients and with patients who did not fulfill any inclusion criteria. RESULTS: In total, 2,258 patients with SSc-ILD were included: 31.2% of the patients met SENSCIS criteria; 5.8% of the patients met SLS II criteria; 1.6% of the patients met focuSSced criteria, and 67.7% (1,529) of the patients did not meet any criteria. In the first 12 + 3 months, the absolute FVC decline in all patients and in patients who fulfilled criteria from SENSCIS was -0.1%, in patients who fulfilled criteria from focuSSced was -3.7%, and in patients who fulfilled criteria from SLS II was 2.3%, with accompanying more progressors in focuSSced. The patient populations that fulfilled the different study inclusion criteria significantly differed in various clinical parameters. In the second 12-month period, SENSCIS-enriched patients had a further absolute FVC% decline as described for the total cohort. In contrast, patients who fulfilled the focuSSced and SLS II criteria showed numeric improvement of lung function. There were no significant associations of enrichment criteria and ILD progression.INTERPRETATION: The application of enrichment criteria from previous clinical trials showed enrichment for progression with variable success, which led to selected patient populations reducing feasibility of recruitment. These findings are important for future clinical trial design and interpretation of the results of published trials.CHEST 2023; 163(3):586-598I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.
