Divergences between Rorschach and MMPI-II in Psychopathy: A forensic case report

This study aims to investigate the divergences observed in the results obtained from the MMPI-II and Rorschach Test in psychopathic individuals. Through the analysis of a case report, we will discuss the different assessment approaches provided by these two diagnostic tools in the context of capacity to understand and volition. The case will be examined to analyse the discrepancies between the two instruments, with a particular focus on the pathological elements highlighted by the Rorschach Test, including frank thought disturbances, which were not captured by the MMPI-II. Findings suggest that the MMPI-II does not prominently detect pathological elements in the psychopathic subject under assessment. However, the Rorschach Test provides a more comprehensive picture of the functioning, revealing thought disturbances and other relevant indicators. This discrepancy raises important questions regarding the use of diagnostic tools and underscores the importance of considering a multifactorial approach for a comprehensive assessment of psychopathology. In conclusion, the results emphasize the need to integrate different assessment methodologies to achieve a more accurate understanding of psychopathic disorders. The integration of MMPI-II with the Rorschach Test can provide a more comprehensive and in-depth evaluation, enabling more precise identification of thought disturbances and other clinically significant aspects in psychopathic individuals.