Impact-Oriented Microfinance Investment Vehicles: A Preliminary Investigation on the Controversial Link between Performance and Stability

Social impact finance can foster economic and financial stability by promoting investments with social goals and non-speculative financial returns. The aim of this paper is to test whether Microfinance Investment Vehicles (MIVs) — labeled impact-oriented MIVs — contribute to economic and financial stability via their performance. Specifically, we test MIVs financial performance and risk-adjusted performance, assuming that: (i) financial returns below the market rate of return (MRR) are likely to contribute to economic stability via higher social and financial inclusion rates and via the promotion of microentrepreneurship; (ii) higher adjusted returns, characterized by low volatility, support financial stability. Results show that impact-oriented MIVs perform below the MRR only if we look at financial performance; when risk-adjusted performance is taken into consideration, impact-oriented MIVs outperform the market. We tested our results with a comparative sample of alternative MIVs aiming for social impact, but not labeled as impact-oriented. Results show that impact-oriented MIVs outperform the comparative sample, while their risk-adjusted performance is lower than that of alternative MIVs. The analysis shows that the market offers different investment options to investors, blending different level of financial return, risks and social goals, with different potential impact on economic and financial stability.